Publications

Information for Authors of Reviews, Review Essays, Obituaries and Commentaries

General Guidelines

American Anthropologist publishes articles, essays, and research reports; book, film, and exhibit reviews; commentaries, and obituaries. American Anthropologist does not pay authors for their manuscripts nor does it provide retyping, drawing, or mounting of illustrations, or other such services. Those are the responsibility of the author.

Reviews should provide balanced critical assessments that take into account American Anthropologist's diverse readers and their many perspectives and approaches. Accuracy and fairness are paramount in American Anthropologist reviews. Although the editors do not take any particular position regarding any specific book, film, or museum exhibit, they discourage inappropriate remarks, such as gratuitous or ad hominem attacks, and reserve the right to reject reviews deemed inappropriate.

Submissions: Book, Museum Anthropology, Visual Anthropology, and Public Anthropology reviews and essays are solicited by the editors. Scholars who wish to review particular books, films, or museum exhibits may identify themselves to the Editors-in-Chief, Museum Anthropology Editor, Visually Anthropology Editor, and Public Anthropology Editor, respectively. Commentaries on articles and reviews should be submitted directly to the Editors-in-Chief; authors of the articles or reviews commented on are invited to respond.

A note about Obituaries: Please note that obituaries published in American Anthropologist differ from death notices published in Anthropology News. American Anthropologist obituaries are biographical essays of about 2,000 words covering the life and work of the subject. In contrast, Anthropology News death notices are much briefer, and are designed to provide basic information about the deceased (name, dates and places of birth and death, affiliations, major publications, immediate survivors), for the record. While anyone can submit a death notice to Anthropology NewsAmerican Anthropologist obituaries are solicited by the Obituary Editor; suggestions for possible authors of obituaries are welcome, and you can find the current Obituary Editor's contact information below. For more information about Anthropology News death notices and how to submit a notice, please visit the Anthropology News submissions page.

Articles, commentaries, essays, book reviews and book review essays should be sent to the Editors-in-Chief. We prefer to receive them electronically at aaeditor@uci.edu. Manuscripts are acknowledged on receipt.

We do not encourage unsolicited book reviews, but we do not discourage them either. Although we prefer to solicit reviewers ourselves, we will consider unsolicited reviews and offers to review a book. When we receive an unsolicited review or an offer to write a review, we follow the following procedure:

  1. We check to see whether the book has been reviewed, is in the process of being reviewed, or has already been rejected for review. If none of these, we check to make sure that we have the book in the office. If we don't, but may be interested in reviewing it, we order a copy from the publisher. It is our practice to see all books before agreeing to having them reviewed.
  2. Once we have the book in hand, we determine whether or not we want to review the book in American Anthropologist.
  3. If we decide to have the book reviewed, we then consider the source of the unsolicited review or offer to review in order to ensure that the reviewer is an appropriate one in terms of expertise and that there are no obvious personal connections that might bias the review (e.g., the reviewer is cited in the acknowledgments)

Material for the Obituary, Museum Anthropology, Visual Anthropology, and Public Anthropology sections should be sent to the editors of those sections, not to the Editors-in-Chief. Contact information for these editors can be found at the bottom of this page.

Author Responsibilities: Authors must recognize that they [not the American Anthropological Association (AAA)] are responsible for the content of their articles, for the accuracy of quotations and their correct attribution, for the legal rights to publish any material submitted, and for submitting their review, commentary, or review essay in proper form for publication. A manuscript submitted to the American Anthropologist must not be under consideration by any other journal at the same time or have been published elsewhere.

Evaluation: Commentaries, review essays, reviews, and obituaries are reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief and/or the appropriate section review editors. The editors reserve the right to reject or return for revision any submitted material on the grounds of inappropriate subject matter, quality, length, or nonconformity with the AAA style guide. Solicitation of book reviews does not guarantee publication. We will, however, be delighted to publish a review that adheres to the below standards.

When writing your review, we request that you consider the following guidelines: Please do not simply summarize or list each chapter. Instead, we ask that you offer substantive commentary on, for example, the quality of the theory, methodology, and writing, or the relevance of the research to other current or recently published work. When reviewing an edited volume, do not feel that you must write about, or even mention, every chapter. Instead describe the overall focus of the volume, pick a few significant contributions and discuss those in detail. Finally, please do not exceed the word limit, avoid lengthy direct quotations and minimize outside references.

Edited manuscript: Edited manuscripts are sent to authors, who should answer any queries and respond to suggested substantive changes. Authors should retain copies for their records.

Galley proofs: Authors of reviews and commentaries do not receive galleys, even though minor copy-edited changes may have been made, unless authors specifically request them at the time they submit their approval of substantive edited changes. If requested, galleys will be returned to you in pdf format. As always, no substantive changes will be allowed at this point and any new changes and additions are treated as suggestions. AAA reserves the right to bill you for substantial alterations. For corrections to be taken into account on the pdf version of the master galley, corrected galley proofs must be mailed to the Production Editor within 48 hours of receipt.

Final Page Proofs: No page proofs are sent to authors; the AAA Department of Publication Services is responsible for ensuring that all indicated corrections are made on the final page proofs.

Reprints: Authors may order reprints directly from the printer. Camera-ready copy of an author's contribution is available to that author from the AAA for one year from printing time at no cost.

 

Review Editor Contact Information

New books for review and correspondence

The Co-Editors for Book Reviews are:
Rosemary A. Joyce
Department of Anthropology
University of California, Berkeley

Justin B. Richland
Department of Criminology, Law, and Society
University of California, Irvine

Send all books for review and inquiries to:

Rosemary A. Joyce, Co-Editor, Book Reviews
American Anthropologist
Kroeber Hall #3710
Berkeley, CA 94720-3710
rajoyce@berkeley.edu

New film and video reviews and related correspondence

Marc L. Moskowitz
Visual Anthropology Review Editor, American Anthropologist
Department of Anthropology
University of South Carolina
Columbia, SC 29208
moskowit@mailbox.sc.edu

New obituary information and correspondence

Sydel Silverman
Obituary Editor
4 Blueberry Hill Road
Irvington, NY 10533
Ssilvwolf@aol.com

New Public Anthropology Reviews correspondence

Melissa Checker

Department of Urban Studies

250 Powdermaker Hall

Queens College/CUNY

6530 Kissena Blvd.

Flushing, NY 11367

publicanthreviews@gmail.com




AAA Highlights
CPIMAGE:28806|Philadelphia City Hall 2009 Annual Meeting
  • Online program
      & itinerary
  • Registration -
      Deadline 10/15
     
  • Workshops

    Read more >>
  •  
     
    camera Photo Contest Closing Soon
    Submit your photos online by October 15, 2009.
    Enter today >>
     
     
    Nominations for 2010 Elections AAA Leadership Nominations
    Submit nominations for the 2010 AAA elections by October 12, 2009.
    Read more and submit today >>
     
     
     
     
    New Features
    In Focus: Reflections on Anthropology News
    In Focus: Reflections on Anthropology News
    A new forum where Anthropology News readers can discuss issues central to “In Focus” thematic commentary series and other AN content.
    We welcome your comments!
    We welcome your comments!>
     
     
    What do you think?
    What do you think?
    We appreciate your feedback on the new site.
    Take our 3 minute survey>